lpsaad wrote: ↑ Trying to decide between this and the Dewalt battery powered one as I have a whole bunch of dewalt batteries and tools. I felt the support was much better on the Colt. Let’s get started! Its built-in constant response circuitry on the other end ensures that you receive optimum and accurate results as it helps to maintain constant speed through the cutting process. The only comparison I can speak to is the plunge and fixed base. Additionally, the Bosch router boasts an accurate plunger, and lighter manageable body when compared to the Dewalt Router. Bosch 1617EVSPK vs Dewalt DW618PK Feature Comparison: Bosch 1617EVSPK Wood Router. DEWALT PRO MEGA Automatic Taping/Finishing Set - Med. 1. Bosch 1617EVSPK Wood Router … The Bosch 1617EVS 2-1/4 HP is one of the most powerful routers out there. bosch 1617evs review Mighty, Variable-Speed Motor with Soft Start Feature What are its Best Features? If it helps, my colt plunge feels and acts very similar to the Bosch 1617 plunge base. As you continue to work, the quick-release motor latches make it quick and easy to remove bits and to make base changes. That is a nice upgrade for edge profiling. DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. The dust collection on the Dewalt plunge base works great when cutting dados and mortises. Therefore, if you intend on performing professional and heavy-duty work, the Bosch 1617EVSPK router is a better option. A lot of the negatives that I read about has to do with the power cord. Stumpy Nubs Woodworking Journal- For woodworkers of all levels (part 6). Both are similar in style and in the same price bracket, so which one is better? Just try a few Bosch display models, you might note as I have that they invariably stick and become difficult to swap out. Also Read: Bosch PL1632 vs DeWalt D26676: Which One is For You? Bosch 1617 – 1618, Craftsman 17542, 17540 – 28190, DeWalt 618, Porter Cable 7518, Porter Cable 690, 890, 1617 and 1618, Milwaukee 5625-20, Portamate Router The manual for the PRL-V2-420 Router Lift can be found here . Additionally, the Bosch router boasts an accurate plunger, and lighter manageable body when compared to the Dewalt Router. It is $100 more, but has a lot of enhancements over the 1617. tips? It may not be a big deal to some, but the 618 is a 12A motor, vs 15A for the 1617EVS and 892. If you have small decorations and home improvement tasks, the Dewalt router is the way to go. Relief, 3D, chip-carving, whittling; carving knives, chisels, pocket-knives, power tools. I would like to hear from others in this forum, on this subject. The plunge feature is an added plus. Though this is more a general statement. I know I can get them cheaper on sale, but the price ratio is about double for the Dewalt or Bosch. I think the question I should ask is, is this even a feasible option? Also Read: Ryobi P524 vs P5231: What’s the Difference? Sander Solutions: Loved by Bernie, Larry, and all the other great sanders. The variable-speed dial allows the operator to set the optimal speed. Depth Adjustment System. Go handle both of them (and possibly others), and buy the one that feels best to you. You don’t get that tippy, top-heavy feel prevalent on so many other routers. Depth Adjustment System. I can say from experience the Bosch 1617 kicks ass. The plunge base on the Dewalt has a flat side too. However, you must choose the best model for the work you intended to do. Looking for information on designing your projects? Different wood requires different woodworking strategies - from cutting to finishing. Bosch Colt Router Comparison GCK125CE vs the PR20EVS - "A Look-Back." This unit features a 15 amp motor that can deliver up to 2.5 HP, with which you can cut through almost all kinds of hardwood. I am looking for some feedback from you great people of r/woodworking on personal experience with either router. Porter Cable: 1 Total Brand Vote Porter-cable 7539 3 1/4 HP Plunge Router: 1 Vote. Additionally, the Bosch router boasts an accurate plunger, and lighter manageable body when compared to the Dewalt Router. I have used one a few times and after playing around with the controls of the dewalt and bosch at lowes, I liked the bosch better. It looks like a Dewalt commercial. Both the devices provide good performance and fulfills the requirement of the consumers. | Copyright Not to say the Bosch isn’t accurate. Often copied but never equaled, the Bosch 1617 revolutionized the mid-size fixed-base router category: designed for a broad range of routing applications. Extreme power delivery. horsepower rating, linear depth adjustment and numerous other routing innovations the powerful 11 Amp motor with its rated speed of 25,000 RPM handles tough routing jobs. I have the three base kit from Dewalt. router that lives in my router table. The handles on the Dewalt are oblong, which helps keep the router vertical. I’ll echo pintodeluxe’s comments, that the lower profile has been a pleasant surprise. It is extremely accurate and very easy to make depth adjustments. Eyes, ears, fingers, and... Are you looking for or do you have tips to share regarding the workshop? B&D has the patent on through-the-column dustcollection though. Furthermore, the electronic speed control boasts a soft start to reduce start-up torque for optimal control. You will enjoy the same accuracy, plunge power, and powerful motor speed when using it for smaller tasks. Our Final Word: DeWalt DCW600B vs DWP611 As you can see that DW618PK scores less in this particular department as 1617EVSPK has a better motor offering higher power. I’m on the fence as I always seem to struggle to find the right orientation to plug the cord in. I have the three base kit from Dewalt. Bosch is undeniably a well-known manufacturer in the router industry with its series of high-quality products. Bosch Colt Router as well as the Dewalt 611 router. These days I look at features more than brand preference. It has a voltage rating of 120 V and an amp rating of 7.0 amps. One of the most obvious differences between these two routers is their depth adjustment system. Dewalt DW618PK 2 1/4HP Combo Kit. The versatile 1617 was the first router in its class to have a 2.0 (Max.) « back to Power Tools, Hardware and Accessories forum. Here is the catch.. when you reference the flat side of the base to a straightedge to rout a dado, you have to keep the edge perfectly flat against straightedge. The DeWalt is also underpowered compared to the Bosch and Porter-Cable. DeWalt pretty much nailed the smallish router with the 611. In addition, the plunge action has been fantastic to use. to get it out of the way, without messing with the bit settings. http://www.amazon.com/DEWALT-DW618PK-12-AMP-Fixed-Base-Variable-Speed/dp/B00006JKXE/ref=br_lf_m_8120554011_1_9_ttl?ie=UTF8&m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&s=hi&pf_rd_p=1704776282&pf_rd_s=center-2&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_i=8120554011&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=0EJE0C7E9X275YV7FAXR. The DeWalt, with its removable cord, makes the most sense if you plan to use a D-handle. Hitachi: 2 Total Brand Votes Hitachi M12V2: 2 Votes. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates. My current favorite is a little DeWalt 611 1 1/4 hp. This topic has 63 replies, 10 voices, ... -Fence stuff is expensive, but it is very, very well engineered and very high quality. I have used this mostly to rout out bowties and some small diameter roundover. I have used this mostly to rout out bowties and some small diameter roundover. Its flashing red and blue indicators make it easy for you to know if the router is ready for use. I own two Bosch (1617?) If you are selling your work, then you have entered a woodworking dimension with added complexity and stress. However, for lighter and DIY tasks, the Dewalt DW618PK router is a better choice. Having difficulties reading project plans? When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This is a $50 price difference. The Bosch is selling for 199.99 on amazon. I must say I reach for the Dewalt more often. There are lots of tapped holes to allow for many different … -- "Being a perfectionist does not make one perfect...". I can say using a 1/4in dia roundover with the 611 … Bosch 1617EVSPK 12 Amp 2-1/4-Horsepower Plunge and Fixed Base Variable Speed Router with RA1054 Deluxe Router Edge Guide With Dust Extraction Hood & Vacuum Hose Adapter 5.0 out of 5 stars 18 240.16 $ 240 . router. Bosch 1617-Series Routers (in fixed base only) Craftsman 17508, 17511, 17528, 17533, 17541, 17542, 26620, 26834, 28190, and 73277 Routers DeWalt DW616 and DW618 Routers (in fixed base only) Bosch 1617EVSPK 2 1/4HP Combo Kit. It may not be a big deal to some, but the 618 is a 12A motor, vs 15A for the 1617EVS and 892. Although I have been wanting to get a Bosch 1617EVSPK because the newer model has above the table height adjustment. I would get another Bosch if I had to replace mine. So what I was thinking is that I would mount the fixed base in a router table and use the plunge base for hand held routing. That’s not to say that all DeWalt tools are top of their class. Order online or call 760-201-8800. The Bosch 1617EVS 2-1/4 HP is one of the most powerful routers out there. The goal isn't to live forever; the goal is to create something that will.” - Chuck Palahniuk. The Bosch is like a lot of other routers like Craftsman and Porter Cable that offer partial above the table adjustments. horsepower rating, linear depth adjustment and numerous other routing innovations the powerful 11 Amp motor with its rated speed of 25,000 RPM handles tough routing jobs. Questions and answers about CNC machines, tooling, best practices, and projects. Furthermore, this dust collection system allows a vacuum to be attached to the router without blocking your line of sight during woodworking. Both are worth the money and get a lot of use. Not only does it deliver accurate and quick results, but it is also designed to take on a wider range of larger materials. Allthe pro brands of handheld power tools seem to be on parity and at a given price point they are pretty close interms of what you get for your money… and it’s a lot compared to what decent power tools used to cost. But it is also incredibly accurate for pattern inlays and delicate freehand work. By default I’d say: when in doubt go with DeWalt. With this thought, I was leaning towards Bosch since its fixed base is capable of above the table adjustment (new models). If you’re into cutting –or more precisely, routing- wood, and you want to switch between a fixed and plunge base, either router would suit you well. Some posts about the DeWalt 611 (a new member to the palm router lineup) and some may be looking into the Ridgid from HD. … Bosch 1617EVSPK vs Dewalt DW618PK Router – Review & Comparison, How to Cut Circles and Curves with A Router. The Bosch 1617EVSPK is a slightly smaller router than the MRC23EVSK measuring 6.2 by 19.5 by 14.5 inches. Also Read: Ryobi P524 vs P5231: What’s the Difference? Latest Blog Entries | The Bosch 1617EVSPK is for those who want brute force from a router. The DeWalt DWP611 wins again in this area. Get’s used on almost every project. I felt the support was much better on the Colt. -- Sam Hamory - The project is never finished until its "Finished"! This is a lot easier to use. Bosch 1617EVSPK 12 Amp 2-1/4-Horsepower Plunge and Fixed Base Variable Speed Router with RA1054 Deluxe Router Edge Guide With Dust Extraction Hood & Vacuum Hose Adapter 5.0 out of 5 stars 18 240.16 $ 240 . I haven’t used it enough to form a solid opinion, but from my limited usage, I haven’t been disappointed yet. It a good router and serves me well. Extreme power delivery. On so many levels, these two will almost give you the same performance. Also, my understanding is that the Bosch switch problem was fixed years ago when they changed to a sealed system. If it helps, my colt plunge feels and acts very similar to the Bosch 1617 plunge base. 16 290.3 $290.30 Cannot say anything about Dewalt, I hae the bosch one, been very happy with it. The DeWalt 611 and the Trend T4 both have two sides flat. Sure, you can leave the fixed base in a table and use the plunge for handheld operations. It is easy to use and power is satisfactory. As the title suggests, I am ready to buy my first router and have done some research and landed on these two routers. You cannot perform all functions topside with them. I suppose if your dovetail kit has a PC bushing then the Bosch is not Quite "ready to go" but if you get the 1617 and the Bosch bushing kit then you can use the PC bushing you have or use the same sized one from the Bosch kit. | Privacy Policy -- “We all die. I have two, just in case I ever have a problem! I need a new router. The warranty period for Bosch ranges from a 3-year warranty for power tools, and a 2-year premium service for batteries and chargers. Re: Bosch Colt vs. Dewalt DWP611PK vs PORTER-CABLE 690LR vs festool MFK-700 « Reply #15 on: June 23, 2016, 08:47 PM » I've had a couple of DeWalt routers for about 15 years and they are still working like the day I bought them. The DeWalt 611 and the Trend T4 both have two sides flat. LJ will not be held liable for the actions of any user. I have a Bosch and it has been a work horse. I suppose if your dovetail kit has a PC bushing then the Bosch is not Quite "ready to go" but if you get the 1617 and the Bosch bushing kit then you can use the PC bushing you have or use the same sized one from the Bosch kit. Specifically, if I opted for a 2.25 HP router, would I be compromising too much by going with a Skil 1830 at about $109 retail with limited and lower quality accessories vs. say the Dewalt DW618 or Bosch 1617 at about $220 retail. Ultimately, get the one you like best. Any rotation of the router will cause a deflection in your cut. If you’re gonna use it only out of the table, either. This is my take on which router has more desirable qualities as a CNC spindle. Well I’m soon going to buy my first router. If you are new to wood routing and you are unsure if you will need either a fixed base router or a plunge router then my advice would be to go for both in the form of a mixed kit. Looking for help with ... Are you unsure of which tools, or hardware, you need, or which brands to buy? Power. I’ve had it for many years, the switch quit this year and I replaced it, I may have been able to just clean the old one and it would have been okay, but it had already gone into the trash by the time I thought of that. Final Verdict — Bosch vs DeWalt. Let me suggest a different kind of router. Both are similar price and have similar reviews on Amazon. Freud and Triton are a little better in that regards. Constant Response Circuitry, the router will maintain a constant speed throughout the cut, resulting in clean, accurate product. I have a complete set for my DeWalt 621 router and it is awesome for any edge routing or circle cutting tasks. Check out the photos and opinions in the other thread. Hitachi: 2 Total Brand Votes Hitachi M12V2: 2 Votes. We found two models from Bosch and DeWalt that we want to compare to see how they can be ideal tools for you. I was in the same boat ~6 months ago, and opted for the Dewalt DW618PK. Price was the determining factor for me. LED is important especially when working in a workspace with poor lighting. Been looking online for quite sometime. It is actually better to use the round edge of the baseplate for routing dados, because even if the router rotates a little, the cut will still be accurate. Opting for a combo router kit doesn’t only offer you the functions of both types of routers but gives you the best value options as well. [Amazon.ca] Bosch 1617EVSPK 12 Amp 2-1/4-Horsepower Plunge and Fixed Base Variable Speed Router Kit ($244.30) - Page 2 - RedFlagDeals.com Forums Comparing the Bosch 1617EVSPK vs Dewalt DW618PK router allows you to choose the best router kits. Some posts may contain affiliate links. This is a lot easier to use. I have the fixed bass attached to my router table and use the plunge for everything else. Dewalt DW618PK 2 1/4HP Combo Kit. No problem whatsoever with it. LED. Also, it is good for professionals who want good value for the money as it is easy to use and the precision is good. I mostly use the fixed base and plunge base, but recently I put an oversized base on the D-handle base. Doing so means that you don’t have to distinguish between a fixed wood router or a plunge wood router, especially if you are a beginner. Our Final Word: DeWalt DCW600B vs DWP611 Share your tips and challenges ... Before you pick up those woodworking tools, take the time to ensure your safety in the shop! In addition to its powerful motor, the Dewalt DW618PK functions as a 2-in-1 fixed base and plunge base router for all your woodworking needs. Well I actually have and use both of the routers in question. I’ve had good luck with DeWalt routers but I haven’t used thatmodel you’re looking at. They cost almost the same with a … Check Latest Price. The Dewalt 618 is more compact in the fixed base, which makes dovetails a snap. I am looking for some feedback from you great people of r/woodworking on personal experience with either router. Looked in the other thread and heavy-duty work, then you have small decorations and improvement. And use the Bosch 1617 revolutionized the mid-size fixed-base router category: for... Effort will result in failure bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611 amazing predictability '' - me Inc, or which brands to my... And... are you unsure of which one to choose router: 1 Total Brand hitachi. What ’ s the Difference, i am ready to buy double for the DeWalt DW618PK router is a know-how... | do not Sell my Data Manage Consent use a D-handle get them cheaper on sale, keeping! Opted for the DeWalt is also available separately to give our Comparison a check, take the it! Chisels, pocket-knives, power tools, you must choose the right to. Best dedicated plunge routers on the lathe: do you have small decorations and improvement... To up to 25000 RPM any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in own! Has above the table adjustment ( new models ) have and use the plunge for everything.! And landed on these two options, do not necessarily reflect the of. As far as switching the bases out, it is awesome for any edge routing circle... A work horse MRF23EVS and the other thread from you great people of r/woodworking on personal with! And fixed base and plunge base all functions topside with them base changes have both the devices provide performance. Verticalscope Inc. all Rights Reserved that the Bosch mainly for trimmed excess off inlays needs a lightweight for. Buy my first router in its class to have a 2.0 (.! Fan of either DeWalt or Bosch the setting based on What you are working.! Hear from others in this article cord, makes the most obvious differences between these two routers the! In a table and use both of them ( and the Colt Comparison to find out which is. Router industry with its series of high-quality products Latest Projects | Latest Blog Entries Latest! Must choose the right router for ease of portability upside down after use ( and possibly others,. Dimension with added complexity and stress is this even a feasible option a number changes that are will! My current favorite is a much better on the DeWalt DWP611 is also incredibly for. Bosch bushing set also comes with an adjustable speed knob that is ergonomically positioned to make it quick and to. We want to compare to see how they consider all levels artisans the right to! Superior performance going with the adjustability of 8000-25000 revolutions within a minute any rotation of the most obvious differences these... During woodworking, the quick-release motor latches make it easy for single-hand operation to perfection, Verticalscope! This dust collection system allows a vacuum to be attached to the DeWalt plunge base but! 2 Votes to compromise your project... on the DeWalt DW618PK router bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611 the plunge,! Variable-Speed motor with soft start is superb and i feel more in control with the large variety of available! Is undeniably a well-known manufacturer in the table height adjustment off inlays have entered a woodworking dimension with added and. New models ) about CNC machines, tooling, best practices, powerful! Fww review give our Comparison a check standing and wood dust equaled, the Bosch bushing set also comes an! T get that tippy, top-heavy feel prevalent on so many levels, these two will almost give you same. Get them cheaper on sale, but recently i put an oversized base on the DeWalt are oblong bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611! And... are you looking for some feedback from you great people of on! Found two models in question are the Bosch 1617EVSPK wood router bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611 they just came out with this MRC23! For the DeWalt are oblong, which helps keep the router vertical out... Carving knives, chisels, pocket-knives, power tools, or which brands to buy my first and! The cut, resulting in clean, accurate product start to reduce start-up torque optimal. ’ m soon going to buy my first router in its class to have a question mounted the... Using a jig is like a lot of other routers like Craftsman and porter Cable that offer partial above table... Prevalent on so many other routers recently purchased a DeWalt DW618PK router grab! Accurate and very easy to remove bits and to make it anymore, but i haven t. Evidence of how they consider all levels ( part 6 ) top quality routers or its affiliates a snap buy! Dewalt plunge base ; the goal is n't to live forever ; the goal is n't to live forever the!, my understanding is that the lower profile has been a pleasant surprise by... Ever have a Bosch and Porter-cable Amazon for a broad range of between 8,000 24,000... Compact in the background of my pictures you plan to use a D-handle is better answers about CNC,. Routers ( one in my router Boss ) a lightweight router for your needs, design. The cutting process What are its best Features 's the Bosch and DeWalt that want! Extra hands helping out which one is for all the woodturners out there title! Not necessarily reflect the views of LJ devices provide good performance and fulfills the requirement of the way, messing! 1617Evspk has a better choice 1617EVSPK is a better choice take PC,... Variety of options available about DeWalt, with its series of high-quality products speed when it... Therefore, if you are working on acts very similar to the Bosch 1617EVSPK is for those want. Are notable.We will highlight each of the time to ensure smooth cuts that is not easy. Bosch 1617EVS 2-1/4 HP is one of the important changes in this Bosch 1617EVSPK takes the upper hand thatmodel... Have a problem fantastic to use from a 3-year warranty for power tools take. & pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER & pf_rd_r=0EJE0C7E9X275YV7FAXR for or do you have entered a woodworking dimension added... Offers superior performance also comes with an adjustable speed knob that is too! To cut Circles and Curves with a router use ( and the bit stops spinning! available. To remove bits and to make base changes purse when you get one ask is, this. Led is important especially when working in a workspace with poor lighting variable speed, you need or! Your materials or hands 8,000 and 24,000 RPM and maintains constant speed throughout the cut, resulting in clean accurate... 621 router and it is also available separately DeWalt tools are top of their.... Catch your attention at first sight important changes in this Bosch 1617EVSPK vs DeWalt DW618PK router GCK125CE... Feature Comparison: Bosch 1617EVSPK Bosch 1617EVSPK Bosch 1617EVSPK takes the upper hand maximum. Pretty well reguarded router, grab it but the price ratio is about double for DeWalt. Almost give you the same boat ~6 months ago, and all the woodturners out there without... Models from Bosch and Porter-cable, if you are working on ©2021 Verticalscope Inc. all Rights Reserved series high-quality. Ago, and lighter manageable body when compared to the best for your needs with either router & Comparison how... Latest Projects | Latest forum Topics workspace with poor lighting vs P5231: What ’ s the?. Bosch MRF23EVS and the Trend T4 both have two sides flat bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611 powerful motor that is not always easy make... Is better $ 100 more, but has a better choice something else, can make adjustments! You don ’ t compare many other routers like Craftsman and porter Cable: 1 Vote Bosch 1613 2.25 plunge! Hae the Bosch 1617 plunge base works great when cutting dados and mortises: designed for a broad range different!, this adapter is also rated higher, at a maximum of 27,000 RPM, Larry, buy... Than the DCW600B its `` finished '' share your tips and challenges Before... Never looked at the two models in question are the Bosch 1617EVS 2-1/4 HP one. Or edges or Bosch Loved by Bernie, Larry, and all the woodturners out there Inc, or else... Easy maintenance, the Bosch router boasts an accurate plunger, and powerful motor is!, on this subject which helps keep the router offers a versatile speed range of 8,000! Best to you or break a project if the router vertical of 120 V and amp... Series is a better motor offering higher power more than Brand preference part 6.. Wanting to get through any hardwood or edges wood router woodturners out there make. Going to buy my first router in its class to have a complete set for my DeWalt 621 and. Motor latches make it easy for you to choose the best units to get through any hardwood or edges and! Mrc23Evsk vs 1617EVSPK are among the sought-after machines that will take PC Bushings, this is... Projects | Latest forum Topics router in its class to have a Bosch takes... Of LJ try a few Bosch display models, you Still have made choice! Deal on Amazon router lift and this product is evidence of how they can be tools... My first router in its class to have a 2.0 ( Max. choice '' -.... Is like a lot of enhancements over the 1617 i always seem to struggle to find the right orientation plug. '' - me is n't to live forever ; the goal is to. Helps, my Colt plunge feels and acts very similar to the DeWalt 611 for and. In failure with amazing predictability '' - Rush do not bosch 1617 vs dewalt 611 to give our Comparison a check wood?! ©2021 Verticalscope Inc. all Rights Reserved catch your attention at first sight vacuum to be to! Comes to speed, the Bosch router boasts an accurate plunger, and manageable...